Felt overpriced once I did the math on cost per dose. The taste is the dealbreaker for me — way too artificial and lingers for hours. Does not dissolve well — I end up chewing little lumps, which is unpleasant.

No proprietary-blend nonsense, just clearly dosed ingredients. Great value for the serving count — works out cheaper per dose than the big brands. Far too sweet, almost cloying. I have to mask it with extra liquid.

Smooth flavor with no weird aftertaste, which is rare in this category. Dissolves completely in water, even without a blender. Label is clear about dosing and the bottle doesn't take up much shelf space.

Packaging is sturdy and the freshness seal was fully intact on arrival. For what you pay, the ingredient quality is excellent. Ingredient list has more fillers than I'd like for the price.

Ingredient list has more fillers than I'd like for the price. Clumps badly no matter how long I shake it; gritty residue settles at the bottom.

Cost per serving is lower than my old brand and the quality is at least as good. You can tell this is a quality formulation; transparent labeling and third-party tested. Scoop was buried at the very bottom — minor, but annoying out of the gate.