The seal was broken on arrival, which made me nervous about freshness. Clumps badly no matter how long I shake it; gritty residue settles at the bottom. Felt overpriced once I did the math on cost per dose.

Wish the dosing were more transparent instead of a proprietary blend. Not worth the premium — comparable products cost less per serving. The seal was broken on arrival, which made me nervous about freshness.

Clean ingredient list with no fillers I didn't recognize — exactly what I look for. Recovery between sessions has clearly improved; less soreness the next day. Does not dissolve well — I end up chewing little lumps, which is unpleasant.

Zero clumping, which I appreciate since my old one needed a whisk every time. Recovery between sessions has clearly improved; less soreness the next day. Consistent quality across every tub I've bought so far. The seal was broken on arrival, which made me nervous about freshness.

Does not dissolve well — I end up chewing little lumps, which is unpleasant. Far too sweet, almost cloying. I have to mask it with extra liquid.

You can tell this is a quality formulation; transparent labeling and third-party tested. Great value for the serving count — works out cheaper per dose than the big brands. There's a chalky, medicinal aftertaste I just can't get past.