Clumps badly no matter how long I shake it; gritty residue settles at the bottom. Pricey for what you get, and the serving size is smaller than it looks.

Dissolves completely in water, even without a blender. Cost per serving is lower than my old brand and the quality is at least as good. Resealable tub keeps everything fresh and the scoop sits right on top. Ingredient list has more fillers than I'd like for the price.

Started noticing better recovery after about two weeks of consistent use. The price-to-quality ratio here is hard to beat; I've already reordered twice.

Resealable tub keeps everything fresh and the scoop sits right on top. Mixes clean with just a shaker bottle — no clumps and no grit at the bottom.

Does not dissolve well — I end up chewing little lumps, which is unpleasant. The seal was broken on arrival, which made me nervous about freshness. Used it consistently for six weeks and honestly felt no difference at all.

Smooth flavor with no weird aftertaste, which is rare in this category. Arrived sealed and well packaged, with a scoop that was actually easy to find. The price-to-quality ratio here is hard to beat; I've already reordered twice.