Far too sweet, almost cloying. I have to mask it with extra liquid. Clumps badly no matter how long I shake it; gritty residue settles at the bottom. Didn't notice any of the benefits the label promises, even after a full bottle.

Zero clumping, which I appreciate since my old one needed a whisk every time. Honestly tastes like a treat rather than a chore.

The price-to-quality ratio here is hard to beat; I've already reordered twice. Consistent quality across every tub I've bought so far. Smooth flavor with no weird aftertaste, which is rare in this category.

You can tell this is a quality formulation; transparent labeling and third-party tested. Cost per serving is lower than my old brand and the quality is at least as good. The seal was broken on arrival, which made me nervous about freshness.

Zero clumping, which I appreciate since my old one needed a whisk every time. Resealable tub keeps everything fresh and the scoop sits right on top. Finally one that doesn't taste artificial. The vanilla is subtle and pleasant. Felt overpriced once I did the math on cost per dose.

Third-party tested and you can tell — this feels like a premium product without the premium markup.