Clumps badly no matter how long I shake it; gritty residue settles at the bottom. Wish the dosing were more transparent instead of a proprietary blend.

Zero clumping, which I appreciate since my old one needed a whisk every time. For what you pay, the ingredient quality is excellent.

Pricey for what you get, and the serving size is smaller than it looks. Scoop was buried at the very bottom — minor, but annoying out of the gate.

Does not dissolve well — I end up chewing little lumps, which is unpleasant. Pricey for what you get, and the serving size is smaller than it looks.

Cost per serving is lower than my old brand and the quality is at least as good. Honestly tastes like a treat rather than a chore. Used it consistently for six weeks and honestly felt no difference at all.

My second tub now. Quality has been identical between orders, which I really appreciate.